Last Updated: June 2025 | By: Ron Johnson, Weekend Golfer & Equipment Reviewer
After six months using the Performance Golf SF1 driver and extensively testing the TaylorMade Qi35 Max, I can finally give you the definitive comparison every senior golfer has been asking for.
As a 59-year-old golfer who's struggled with slice and distance loss, I've put both drivers through rigorous real-world testing to determine which one truly delivers.
📌 Bottom Line Up Front: The SF1 driver reduced my slice by 90% and costs $252 less than the Qi35 Max, while the TaylorMade Qi35 Max offers premium build quality and adjustability for golfers who want maximum customization. Your choice depends on your primary need: slice correction vs. premium features.
Driver Comparison Images
SF1 Driver - $297
✅ 90% Slice Reduction | ✅ $297 Price Point
TaylorMade Qi35 Max - $549
✅ Premium Performance | ✅ 12-Position Adjustability
Quick Comparison Chart
| Feature | SF1 Driver | TaylorMade Qi35 Max |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $297 | $549 |
| Best For | Slice correction | Premium performance |
| Weight | 275g | 275g |
| Adjustability | Limited | 12-position hosel |
| Slice Reduction | Exceptional (90% in my case) | Moderate |
| Build Quality | Very Good | Premium |
| Our Rating | 9.5/10 (value) | 9.2/10 (overall) |
My Personal Testing Experience: 6 Months of Real Golf
Before diving into the technical details, let me share my real-world experience with both drivers. As someone who lost 8-10 balls per round to slice before switching drivers, this comparison comes from genuine frustration and eventual relief.
SF1 Driver: The Slice-Killing Game Changer
I've had the SF1 in my bag for six months now, and the transformation has been remarkable:
- Slice Improvement: From losing 8-10 balls per round to 1-2 maximum
- Distance Gains: 15-18 yards average increase due to straighter ball flight
- Confidence Factor: Actually look forward to tee shots now
- Consistency: 78% fairway accuracy vs. 45% with my old driver
Real Round Example: Last Tuesday at my home course, I hit 11 of 14 fairways with the SF1. With my previous driver, 7-8 fairways was a great day.
TaylorMade Qi35 Max: Premium Performance
I tested the Qi35 Max for three weeks, borrowing one from my golf buddy who swears by TaylorMade:
- Distance Performance: Excellent carry distance, comparable to SF1
- Feel and Sound: Premium impact sensation, confidence-inspiring sound
- Adjustability: 12 positions allowed fine-tuning for my swing
- Build Quality: Clearly premium materials and construction
The Reality Check: While the Qi35 Max is an excellent driver, it didn't solve my slice problem the way the SF1 did. I still curved 6-7 drives per round significantly.
Head-to-Head Performance Analysis
For golfers interested in understanding the technical aspects of modern driver performance, Golf.com's equipment guides provide excellent analysis of how different technologies affect ball flight and distance.
🏆 Slice Correction: SF1 Wins Decisively
✅ SF1 Driver Performance:
- Built-in anti-slice technology automatically squares the clubface
- Weight distribution specifically designed to reduce slice spin
- Face angle optimization promotes draw-biased ball flight
- My results: 90% reduction in slice frequency
❌ TaylorMade Qi35 Max Performance:
- Adjustable hosel can help reduce slice with proper fitting
- Forgiving face maintains distance on off-center hits
- Weight positioning aids launch but doesn't specifically target slice
- Reality: Requires swing changes or professional fitting to address slice
Winner: SF1 Driver - No contest here. The SF1 solves slice problems while the Qi35 Max requires you to solve them yourself.
🏆 Distance Performance: Nearly Even
SF1 Driver Distance:
- Average carry: 225 yards (18 yards longer than my old driver)
- Total distance: 245 yards average with roll
- Consistency: 90% of drives within 15-yard distance range
- Launch conditions: High launch, optimal spin for my swing speed
TaylorMade Qi35 Max Distance:
- Average carry: 230 yards (5 yards longer than SF1)
- Total distance: 250 yards average with roll
- Consistency: 85% of drives within 15-yard distance range
- Launch conditions: Adjustable to optimize for different swing speeds
Winner: Slight edge to Qi35 Max - The premium face technology and adjustability can squeeze out a few extra yards.
🏆 Value Proposition: SF1 Dominates
💰 SF1 Driver Value:
- Price: $297 (direct-to-consumer pricing)
- Performance per dollar: Exceptional, especially for slice correction
- Total cost of ownership: No fitting required for most golfers
- Results: Immediate improvement without swing changes
💰 TaylorMade Qi35 Max Value:
- Price: $549 (premium retail pricing)
- Performance per dollar: Good but premium pricing
- Total cost of ownership: May require professional fitting ($100-150)
- Results: Excellent performance with proper optimization
Winner: SF1 Driver - Nearly identical performance at $252 less cost makes this an easy call.
Who Should Choose Each Driver?
✅ Choose the SF1 Driver If You:
✅ Struggle with slice - This is the SF1's primary strength
✅ Want immediate results - Works great right out of the box
✅ Prefer value pricing - Excellent performance under $300
✅ Are a senior golfer - Specifically designed for our swing characteristics
✅ Want simplicity - No complex adjustments needed
✅ Play occasionally - Perfect for weekend golfers
Perfect for: Senior golfers with slice problems who want an immediate, affordable solution.
✅ Choose the TaylorMade Qi35 Max If You:
✅ Want premium brand recognition - TaylorMade's tour-proven reputation
✅ Enjoy equipment customization - 12-position adjustability
✅ Have consistent ball-striking - Can take advantage of premium features
✅ Budget isn't a primary concern - Willing to pay for premium performance
✅ Want professional fitting - Plan to optimize through custom fitting
✅ Play frequently - Will appreciate premium build quality
Perfect for: Accomplished senior golfers who want maximum performance and customization.
Frequently Asked Questions
❓ Q: Can the TaylorMade Qi35 Max be adjusted to reduce slice like the SF1?
💡 A: While the adjustable hosel can help with slice reduction, it requires proper fitting and may not be as effective as the SF1's built-in anti-slice design.
The SF1 solves slice automatically while the Qi35 Max requires optimization. For professional fitting guidance, the PGA of America's club fitting resources can help you find qualified fitters in your area.
❓ Q: Is the SF1 driver's build quality comparable to TaylorMade?
💡 A: The SF1 offers very good build quality for its price point, but TaylorMade's premium materials and construction are noticeably superior.
However, the performance difference doesn't justify the 85% price premium for most golfers. MyGolfSpy's comprehensive driver testing consistently ranks TaylorMade highly for build quality across their entire driver lineup.
❓ Q: Which driver is better for improving my handicap?
💡 A: If slice is your primary issue, the SF1 will likely lower your scores faster through improved accuracy. If you're already accurate but want maximum distance optimization, the Qi35 Max might provide slight advantages.
❓ Q: How do these drivers compare to other options?
💡 A: Both rank among our top choices. You can see how they compare to 6 other excellent options in our comprehensive senior driver review for 2025. For additional technical analysis of driver performance, Golf Digest's equipment testing lab provides excellent insights into modern driver technologies.
Final Verdict: Which Driver Should You Buy?
After six months with the SF1 and extensive testing of the Qi35 Max, here's my honest recommendation:
🎯 For 80% of senior golfers: Choose the SF1 Driver
✅ Solves the biggest problem (slice) immediately
✅ Exceptional value at $297
✅ No fitting required
✅ Designed specifically for senior golfers
🎯 For premium-focused golfers: Choose the TaylorMade Qi35 Max
✅ Premium build quality and brand recognition
✅ Extensive adjustability for optimization
✅ Slight performance edge when properly fitted
✅ Better for frequent players
My Personal Choice
I'm keeping the SF1 in my bag. The slice reduction alone has transformed my enjoyment of golf, and the $252 savings paid for a year's worth of green fees. While I appreciate the Qi35 Max's premium features, the SF1 solves my actual problems better.
🎯 The Bottom Line: Buy the driver that solves your biggest challenge. If that's slice, choose the SF1. If it's optimizing already-good performance, consider the Qi35 Max.
Where to Buy
🛒 Get SF1 Driver from Performance Golf →
🛒 Check TaylorMade Qi35 Max on Amazon →
For more equipment recommendations, check out our senior golf irons review to complete your equipment upgrade.
📧 Have you tried either of these drivers? Leave a comment below sharing your experience - I'd love to hear how they've performed for other senior golfers!
Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. This helps support our testing and review process.